Tablets: RIM BlackBerry Playbook Kicks iPad Browsing-Butt

If you don't know by now, I'm a hardcore Apple fan, but that doesn't mean I don't think for myself. I said back in September 2010 that the BlackBerry Playbook looked like the first true tablet contender to Apple's iPad. Fast forward to the present and RIM has impressed me again with some updates. Part of that killer Playbook package includes Flash support, but what's more -- much faster rendering times for web pages. Here's the update.

Watch the video below, which seems to show Playbook doing everything faster, from pulling up the on-screen keyboard to loading web pages. It even shows marginally better performance on the Acid3 Browser Test:

Now, the intrepid video narrator doesn't exactly explain why the Playbook is doing a better job, and that's why I'm here. It's simple, really: hardware. The Playbook features a dual-core 1GHz CPU, while the iPad features a 1GHz A4 CPU -- no dual cores, just one. The math isn't that simple, but we can roughly say the Playbook is twice as fast. No surprises here. What the narrator also doesn't tell us -- but you can see quite clearly -- is that Flash on the playbook isn't so great. Look closer: Even though it loads up and is functional, you can clearly see the stuttering frame rate in the animations on screen.

Still, there's some things you need to take into consideration:
  1. Apps - even the coolest web browser on the street doesn't hold a candle to a killer app library and consumer demand. Right now, iPad is the winner.
  2. January 2010 is coming soon. Did you forget about iPad 2, RIM? Apple may not up-the-ante on hardware, but I find it hard to believe Apple is just going to release the iPad with the same exact hardware plus a FaceTime camera. By the time RIM gets Playbook out the door, Apple may have already usurped potential buyers with a new announcement.
All those things being said, it still stands that the Playbook is shaping up to be one of the most polished, true powerful contenders in the tablet arena. (That's my opinion, at least.)

It's foolish to think Apple isn't taking note. That doesn't mean Apple will actively compete against RIM Playbook, but they know it's there. I said said it a lot this time last year -- calling 2010 the year of the tablet, but it's really been the year of the iPad. Longer term, 2011 may turn out the real tablet wars we've been waiting to see.

Sign up for The VAR Guy’s Weekly Newsletter, Webcasts and Resource Center. Follow The VAR Guy via RSS, Facebook and Twitter. Follow experts at VARtweet. Read The VAR Guy’s editorial disclosures here.

Discuss this Video 3

on Nov 18, 2010
The Melissa: Classic reference.
The Melissa (not verified)
on Nov 17, 2010
Well, the geek in this video sold me the RIM. I don't care how, I want it now! =Veruca Salt.
JasunX (not verified)
on Jul 3, 2011
You've stated some valid points. But speed doesn't count for everything. I got an iPad when t was first launched - and yeah I was impressed with the device. But sold it a few months later - for me, the device was not practical. I'm talking usability - User Interface. The iPad is just a big iPhone...without the Phone of course. The software doesn't do much to adapt to a tablet - boring and too uniform. On the other hand - RIM's QNX on the Playbook is a damn impressive tablet OS. The User Interface, and I'm referring specifically to the multitasking panels that automatically align themselves on your "home" screen when an app is open. It makes using the tablet ten times easier. I think if the iPad can achieve this - coupled with a compact 7" form factor - I'd get me another iPad. But for the time being, I'm waiting for a Playbook 4G to hit the shelves, and if Apple can't give me what I want - then screw em.
Post new comment
or register to use your The VAR Guy ID

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×